I don't really know where to go with this entry. Some of you may know that my cousin Jake Young, always known to me as Jakie, was killed in the Bali terrorist bombing in October 2002. Jakie left behind a lovely wife and a darling son. He and his family were returning from Hong Kong, where Jakie worked as a lawyer, and had stopped for a vacation in Bali. Jakie stayed behind for an extra week to play in a rugby tournament. He had played center for the Nebraska Cornhuskers in the late 1980s and was an All-American and Academic All-American during his stellar college football career. I don't want to write a memorial about Jakie, because his brother-in-law, Ken Hoffman, a columnist living in Houston, wrote a very eloquent and elegant memorial to Jakie after his death that I cannot even hope to replicate.
I just read an article on CNN's website that some of the bombers convicted of the attack in 2002 were requesting a painless death. They wish to be beheaded rather than shot in a firing squad, which I presume is the way the death penalty is carried out in Indonesia. I don't know how beheading would be less painful than a firing squad, but whatever.
I still don't know where to go with this. Maybe I'm just dumbfounded that people who inflicted painful deaths on more than 200 people now want a painless death. Perhaps they should have thought of this before they set off the bombs?
I think I'm more dumbfounded that, although the article doesn't delve into the topic, that these men have not reached a stage of regret and remorse that I would hope any human being would come to after killing more than 200 people and spending six years in jail. I don't know much about Islam. I would have thought that any sane human being, regardless of religion, would have at least looked within to determine whether his actions were a result of misguided dogma. I cannot understand how anyone can justify, and over the years continue to justify in his own mind, killing more than 200 people who were merely living their lives without even considering that he may have made a mistake. Granted, I do not know what thoughts pass through these men's heads. I don't know if, being separated from their families while awaiting death sentences, they think about the families around the world who were brought to their knees in grief as a result of their actions.
I am anti-death penalty. I don't believe that carrying out the death penalty solves anything. I don't believe that any state should have the right to take the life of a human being as punishment for a crime. Wiping these men from the face of the earth won't change what they did, nor will it bring Jakie or anyone else back. Carrying out the death penalty upon these men may actually inspire more young people to dedicate themselves to fanatical religious pursuits. Will executing these men bring some measure of comfort and satisfaction to the families of the dead? I don't know. I can't claim the closeness of being in Jakie's immediate family. But executing these men won't bring me any measure of comfort. I think in some way we would be giving them exactly what they wanted to achieve by executing them--whether it be fame, infamy, or martyrdom.
I'd rather that the world forget about these men. I'd have them suffer the same fate that many of the mentally ill suffered in the U.S. in the last century. Their families dropped them off at the mental institutions and left them, where they died and were cremated, forgotten until recently, when canisters of their remains have been unearthed in dusty basements, some marked, some unmarked and nameless forever. After all, aren't anonymity and indifference the ultimate indignity for those who crave martyrdom at the expense of others?
I just read an article on CNN's website that some of the bombers convicted of the attack in 2002 were requesting a painless death. They wish to be beheaded rather than shot in a firing squad, which I presume is the way the death penalty is carried out in Indonesia. I don't know how beheading would be less painful than a firing squad, but whatever.
I still don't know where to go with this. Maybe I'm just dumbfounded that people who inflicted painful deaths on more than 200 people now want a painless death. Perhaps they should have thought of this before they set off the bombs?
I think I'm more dumbfounded that, although the article doesn't delve into the topic, that these men have not reached a stage of regret and remorse that I would hope any human being would come to after killing more than 200 people and spending six years in jail. I don't know much about Islam. I would have thought that any sane human being, regardless of religion, would have at least looked within to determine whether his actions were a result of misguided dogma. I cannot understand how anyone can justify, and over the years continue to justify in his own mind, killing more than 200 people who were merely living their lives without even considering that he may have made a mistake. Granted, I do not know what thoughts pass through these men's heads. I don't know if, being separated from their families while awaiting death sentences, they think about the families around the world who were brought to their knees in grief as a result of their actions.
I am anti-death penalty. I don't believe that carrying out the death penalty solves anything. I don't believe that any state should have the right to take the life of a human being as punishment for a crime. Wiping these men from the face of the earth won't change what they did, nor will it bring Jakie or anyone else back. Carrying out the death penalty upon these men may actually inspire more young people to dedicate themselves to fanatical religious pursuits. Will executing these men bring some measure of comfort and satisfaction to the families of the dead? I don't know. I can't claim the closeness of being in Jakie's immediate family. But executing these men won't bring me any measure of comfort. I think in some way we would be giving them exactly what they wanted to achieve by executing them--whether it be fame, infamy, or martyrdom.
I'd rather that the world forget about these men. I'd have them suffer the same fate that many of the mentally ill suffered in the U.S. in the last century. Their families dropped them off at the mental institutions and left them, where they died and were cremated, forgotten until recently, when canisters of their remains have been unearthed in dusty basements, some marked, some unmarked and nameless forever. After all, aren't anonymity and indifference the ultimate indignity for those who crave martyrdom at the expense of others?
No comments:
Post a Comment