Saturday, June 7, 2008

Speaking of Change...

Is anyone else out there as excited as I am that Shrub will no longer be president as of 1/20/09? I see bumper stickers with that date and several words, such as "green", "earth" and some other tree-huggy word that I've forgotten (ironically one of said bumper stickers was on a Hummer. At my yoga class. F'ril, y'all.).

When Bush started the war on Iraq, I couldn't believe the storm of propaganda that permeated all of the newscasts, newspapers, and news websites that I observed in what was probably slack-jawed wonder. For example, despite the fact that the UN found in a lengthy report that Iraq had no weapons of mass destruction, our government insisted that they were there, somewhere, lurking, and that Saddam Hussein was just waiting on pins and needles to drop them on the U.S. Similarly, I was awestruck when our Secretary of State stated that there was evidence linking Saddam Hussein to Al Queda. Like a good lawyer, I kept asking myself and others, "But where is the evidence? Shouldn't they show us the evidence before they spend billions of our tax dollars invading a country against which they apparently have no incriminating evidence? Is anybody with me???" For some reason, the "evidence" never materialized, nor was any explanation offered by the U.S. powers that be for why it was never produced (this would get the Powers that Be kicked out of any court in the land with an ounce of sense). They never even attempted to say that it was classified due to national security reasons, or at least not that I heard.

During the swirl of accusations leveled at Iraq, I felt like I was at the center of a hurricane. Friends fumed that we should attack Iraq and any other country that did not offer its condolences after 9/11. I tried to be the voice of reason and point out that this would only create a new generation of disaffected youngsters that would despise the U.S. and then turn into ballistics-toting terrorists. My friends railed against the Dixie Chicks for merely asserting their right to free speech, and I noted that anyone in this country was free to speak his or her mind as a result of a somewhat important document known as the Constitution. I was still stunned to see that so many people failed to question the reasons for which our country went to war. They just bought it--hook, line, and sinker. No questions asked. I, just out of law school, had so many questions that were never answered. And so I watched as our country unleashed a torrent of bombs upon a country whose leader was, in my mind, not guilty of the charges leveled against him, though a monster nonetheless. A monster whose people needed to rise up against him in a civil war, not a monster who needed to be forcibly displaced by an outside power with no evidence.

A few weeks ago, I read a story, buried deeply within a news website, about how there never was evidence that linked Saddam Hussein to Al Qaeda. The story passed like a sigh, undebated and unimportant to those who had bought into the mass hysteria and who could no longer even remember the reasons we went to war. But I remembered. I remembered that we were not offered any evidence at the beginning. And we were not vindicated by any evidence at the end. As a lawyer, I find it shameful that the "case" was brought without an iota of evidence, and those in charge knew that there was a lack of such evidence. As a lawyer, I have turned away clients who had no evidence of their allegations, and if given the chance, I would continue to do so.

As an American and as a human being I find it appalling that so many people who were raised in a country where people are allowed to speak their minds freely and to question authority did not do so. Those of us who did not support the war were labeled as "unpatriotic." I quietly observed that the alleged "patriots" were not patriots until they were confronted with the fact that other countries are not so fond of the U.S. and its policies. Horrors!! Prior to 9/11 they railed against our government and its policies on a regular basis for perceived crises big and small. After 9/11, any criticism of the administration in charge was not to be tolerated and was deemed unpatriotic.

To me, it was shameful that our country did not observe the rule of law that it swears to force upon other countries under the guise of bringing democracy to a state in need of it (which is questionable in itself)--it did not offer us the evidence sufficient to establish by a preponderance or a shadow of a doubt that a war needed to be waged. And in the end, the evidence lauded as incontrovertible at the beginning was nothing but a few words in a speech or a sound bite, ephemeral and elusive as a fairy story, invented in the minds of the few in power at the time and magnified through the bullhorn of a frenzied media.

But I take heart in the fact that some of us never believed it.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Thank you for writing about this issue with such eloquence. I, too, share your assessment that as a country we conflate questioning with treason. And if I may make a hoary rhyme, that defies reason!

Your pal from AV aka Elizabeth

Sua Sponte said...

That was a wonderful rhyme. :)