I recently started a new job as an in-house attorney. My previous gig was as a litigator in the field of asbestos defense, which is fast drying up in Texas due to recent legislation. It involved working up cases for trial, attending depositions, responding to discovery, writing motions, etc. My reasons for leaving? The work just wasn’t there anymore due to the legislation, I had so many big cases that anxiety was driving me out of my mind, and I couldn’t take the lying anymore.
Unless you’ve worked as an asbestos or silica defense attorney, you would not believe the lying that goes on under oath. I’ve heard some outrageous examples of perjury that I won’t recount here, but I will tell you some favorites from my own experiences. The worst liars are the plaintiffs. They will do anything for a buck. They’ve been coached by their attorneys that the more products they identify, the more money they’ll squeeze out of the defendants. It’s a pretty good incentive, especially because most plaintiffs are working class folks who don’t have money to burn. Several hundred thousand dollars in potential settlements will persuade even the best of us to tell some wee white lies.
I once ran across a deposition of a gentleman who had been a roofer. He was a heavy smoker for most of his life and had been diagnosed with lung cancer, which, of course, he and his attorneys claimed was due to asbestos only, notwithstanding the well-known carcinogenicity of cigarette smoke. In order to get the best settlements possible, the plaintiff’s attorney will try to downplay the effects of smoking and turn the focus to the hazards of asbestos. This particular attorney led his client through the following questions:
Q: Sir, have you ever been a smoker?
A: Yes, for about 20 years.
Q: Did you ever try to quit?
A: Yes, but I wasn’t able to quit.
Q: And that’s because you were addicted to the nicotine in cigarettes?
A: Yes.
Q: Now, during that 20 year period when you smoked, did you ever inhale that cigarette smoke?
A: No, never.
Huh? Why else did he use cigarettes if not to inhale the smoke? And wouldn’t he have put himself even more at risk by just having a lit cigarette hanging out of his mouth, now that we know that secondhand smoke is as or even more dangerous than firsthand smoke? Did he and his attorney actually think that a jury would be dumb enough to buy this story? I ask you.
Another memorable plaintiff told several lies in a row. It didn’t come to my attention until I had gone through his medical records to find that he had been a raging alcoholic for most of his life, in and out of rehab, with alcohol-induced hepatitis, until at least his 50s. While reading his deposition, I ran across a section where he was asked whether he had ever been a drinker (the answer was “when I was a young man”); whether he ever had been treated for alcoholism (the answer was “no”); whether he had ever had psychiatric treatment (the answer was “no). I proceeded to find at least 100 pages of medical records detailing the extent of his alcoholism until his 50s, his stays in rehab and the concurrent psychiatric/psychological counseling, and his inability to find employment due to alcoholism.
The case ultimately got dismissed, but I could not believe that an attorney would allow a client to weave such a Gordian knot of lies. The best thing to do was to have the guy admit that he was a recovering alcoholic and play upon the jury’s sympathies. At trial, the defendants would have been able to prove easily that he was lying, and he would have had no credibility with the jury. Better to admit to having a character flaw than to be caught in a string of lies that brings the truthfulness of your answers to all other questions into doubt.
If I learned one thing from my foray into asbestos litigation, it’s that it’s better to admit to your mistake up front than lie about it and later have to admit to the mistake AND the web of lies concocted to conceal the mistake.
Thursday, September 13, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
instructions for viagra use what is viagra what does viagra do viagra facts cheap viagra tablets fda on viagra homemade viagra 2007 viagra hmo pharmacy viagra viagra herb alternative viagra uk cheap purchase buy levitra vs viagra viagra and alcohol viagra cheap
Post a Comment